Mary Jaron Kelley <mary@...>
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On Behalf Of
Verna Dunlap via groups.io
Monday, August 3, 2020 11:50 AM
Re: [pdxshelterforum] Portland leases 3 more hotels to shift Covid-19 most-vulnerable from shelters or shared housing
Now that the dust is settling, let's buy them up. We will need these anyway in the future.
Verna Dunlap, CEO LCT4vets
On Fri, Jul 31, 2020 at 1:21 PM Marilyn Mauch <m_mauch@...> wrote:
It just seems a travesty that the planning doc you attached -- that the city has a timeline of March 2021 which just seems like too late to wrap up their thinking,
but we have to live with it, in addressing alternative housing models. As you note below, it's too bad that an article didn't appear touting the planning doc you cited and the forum. Is it time for some folks to visit JoAnn Hardesty or has that already
been done? We need an "angel" someplace on the city council that we can collaborate with in advancing/pushing the city forward faster on alternative ways to house those in need. Or, maybe you all have been working on this and I'm just "out of the loop."
My primary community organizing experience has been as the Alliance's rep. to Living Cully's community housing action team under the guidance of Cameron Herrington. Eudaly's staff have been extremely helpful in working together with Living Cully's forward
work. How about a letter to the editor for the Oregonian or is this not a propitious time to do that?
Why don't you contact Molly?.. I think she would be [open] to hearing about alternative approaches to meeting the needs of the unhoused.
I have, many times, including with an announcement about the PDX Shelter Forum event, and about the article mentioned above; have many times shared and complimented her articles. I've often shared to her story angles and back-stories which I think have not
been covered, such as, way back in March when hardly anyone had heard of it, City of Portland's
Shelter to Housing Continuum Program. This is the key City land-use program regarding shelters and homelessness, but has never yet been mentioned in media that I've seen, and it is now approaching the Planning Bureau's very narrow planned window for public
comment, with hardly any public discussion or official proposal released yet.
She interviewed me at length in March, by phone which I generally don't do but she wouldn't do by email/text, after I'd
suggested online that we develop resident-managed villages and campgrounds in response to Covid-19; for a story she said would be coming out on this. (This was before the C3PO camps had been announced). That story never came out, at least not one discussing
the proposals I talked about with her (from Sarah Iannarone, et al). This was the last and one of the few times she's ever engaged.
I don't think this is unusual, or want to blame Molly; I think it's just typical patterns of how traditional media work, that 'stories' mostly follow known narratives, "conventional wisdom", and official/powerful sources. What's interesting to me is how we
might do better, by replacing or supplementing or interoperating this with more open, symmetric, participatory, accumulative, fluid, diverse, & radical media -- rather than 'broadcast'/fixed, centralized, published-once, absentee/commercial/chain-owned like
the The Oregonian. In part, PDX Shelter Forum is for me a small experiment in doing so for a particular topic area.
Great points! More of the history and current efforts/voices/possible solutions need to be included..disseminated!
Yet another article in which the only quoted sources are officials (Mayor, and Joint Office spokesperson Denis Theriault, and the news peg is an official action. You would never know from Oregonian homelessness reporter Molly Harbarger's story that others in
the community have views on this or might have other proposals. Or that Commissioner Hardesty harshly criticized the funding programs recently in City Council hearing for so predominantly focusing on people already in shelter or housing, rather than the unsheltered.
Or that, contrary to the story's and the officials' framing of this effort as for "the vulnerable homeless," homelessness experts widely argue that *all* unhoused, particularly those unsheltered, are highly vulnerable to Covid-19 and other health/safety issues,
and also that the congregate shelters which City/County continue to primarily depend on are considered highly unsafe in general. Or that there are broad community efforts, going back years, to develop alternative shelter models to help more people sooner,
in more private and thus safe ways than these traditional shelters.
For me, this sort of steadily disappointing, narrow, context-less, official/dominant-voice oriented media coverage of homelessness issues is a key reason to build alternative fora such PDX Shelter Forum. We just so clearly get so little of the picture, or possibilities,
or range of voices/views, from traditional media.
"The Joint Office of Homeless Services, funded by the city and Multnomah County, opened three more motels this month to house people who had been lodged in temporary emergency coronavirus shelters in public buildings. There are now four such motels, two of
which the city and county have an option to buy.
"The two governing councils agreed to spend more than $22M from federal CARES Act money on the motel initiative, which includes providing meals and social services such as housing placement, employment help and case management.
"Another $11M is allocated for leasing and operating two motels that hold people who are sick with COVID-19 or show symptoms of the contagious and potentially deadly disease. Those motels also accept people who aren’t homeless, but live in houses or apartments
that don’t have space for them to fully isolate."
"Neither the city nor county boards have so far agreed to purchase the motels they are leasing. Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler appeared to indicate he was open to buying the motels, which he said could later be repurposed into affordable housing. [...]
"Commissioners from both the city and county balked in May at the price tag of leasing motels for use as shelters, saying they wanted to get more than short-term housing from their investment." [...]