Date
1 - 1 of 1
on Ukraine: glimmer of light in DSA
Dayne Goodwin
I learned about this article because John Reimann shared it on a
Ukraine solidarity network list yesterday morning. It is a glimmer of light in the darkness of ultraleft campist dominance on the u.s. "left", including in the DSA's 'International Committee'. What Can the Left Actually Do About Ukraine? by Kyle Shybunko and Alex Gendler Socialist Forum, Winter/Spring 2023 https://socialistforum.dsausa.org/issues/winter-spring-2023/what-can-the-left-actually-do-about-ukraine . . . Much of the Western left analysis of Ukraine begins with a simple premise: a pre-emptive hostility to US military policy, and a conviction that it’s of primary importance for socialists to be seen as opposing it. While this seems to be an obvious application of anti-imperialist principles, it can easily lead us astray. Firstly, it instills a motivated reasoning that undermines our own ability to accurately assess global events. Our discomfort with ending up “on the same side” as NATO or the Pentagon has led many to reach for the most palatable narratives rather than seeking the most accurate analysis of the situation, wherever that takes us. The result is that even outside of explicitly pro-Russia circles it is not uncommon to hear that the popular Maidan uprising was actually a “US-instigated fascist coup”; that the sniper killings that escalated the protests into a confrontation with the state were a “false flag” operation; that Ukraine has killed “14,000 ethnic Russians” in the Donbas region and banned the Russian language; that pro-Russian protesters were “massacred” in Odesa; or that the Minsk Accords failed solely because of Ukraine or the US rather and that the Russian side bears little or no responsibility – all repeated with absolute confidence despite much evidence to the contrary. . . . |
|