What was learned
Dan Margulis
I have no significant disagreement with any of it but would like to add to the point about overthinking. In putting the group together I was aware that certain images, Toast to Greece for example, require a certain amount of time to get a decent result. Therefore I also included some that I thought would be instructive, yet not require any complicated procedure. The comments I got offline indicated that many of you realized that these images should be done fairly quickly, although a few reported spending hours on them. In the six MIT exercises I posted not just my own new version but the ones I had done in 2017 when I was working with a self-imposed limit of three minutes. The new ones were all better IMHO but this was no surprise, because this time I had already seen the previous results (in 2017 I didn’t look at what the MIT retouchers had done until finished with my own version). I would say that the extra time I spent was definitely worth it on Veiled Bride, Cinque Terre, and Red Rose. I’m not sure about Colosseum, it looks like more a question of interpretation than technique. But Monument Valley and Seated in the Grass seem straightforward. I did not overthink them and hope that most of you didn’t either. Dan
|
|