Date
1 - 20 of 24
Email contact oddity - Spam Blacklisted?
Colin Herbert
I have belatedly thought of another route to examining this oddity. Apart
from Siggi and Carsten contacting me directly, maybe others might like to give it a try? My email address can be extracted from that which appears on Tekscopes, but it is: Colingherbert(at)blueyonder(dot)co(dot) uk I will reply directly to any messages that get through to me, so as not to take bandwidth from Tekscopes. TIA, Colin.
|
|
Jean-Paul
Colin I have struggled with similar email disconnects with others.
The only good solution is to have several email providers as alternatives. I have 12 email addresses on various servers and manage with open source client Mozilla Thunderbird. Jon
|
|
Chuck Harris
I think Dennis has it bass-ackwards. The problem is not the
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
receiver, but rather that the receiver's ISP subscribes to a service that knows the sender, Dennis, to be a spam generator. This same problem visited me, maybe a dozen years ago.... I got into an email argument with one of the members of this group, who thought a just punishment for my disagreeing with him would be to disrupt my life, by turning me in to Spamhaus as a spammer. It was a simple act on his part, he just clicked the REPORT SPAM button on the anti-spam plugin he installed on his email program. In a matter of days, emails from my main email address would bounce when I sent them to members of my circle of family and friends. I tracked down my problem to a highly authoritarian European company, Spamhaus, that maintains a list of entities adjudicated by themselves to be serial spammers. This Spamhaus list is the basis of dozens of subscription based spam blocking services used by many ISP's worldwide. All you need to get on Spamhaus's list is for ONE (1) person to click a button on their email program, and report you as a spammer. To get off the list, you must contact Spamhaus and provide them with a host of personal information, and to jump through a few hoops, to prove that you are a real person... As if! I got off the list by threatening my ISP, and a few of the ISP's that subscribe to the offending spam blocking services, with restraint of trade lawsuits. Whether or not Dennis knows it, he is a lightning rod for a group of highly technical miscreants that haunt, or have at one time haunted this group... many of whom are very nasty, vindictive people. Groups.io's solution to the Spamhaus problem is to kick anyone that bounces groups.io emails as spam, off of group.io. -Chuck Harris Colin Herbert via groups.io wrote:
I have belatedly thought of another route to examining this oddity. Apart
|
|
Dave Daniel
If that were the case, Dennis’ emails would bounce, which is not happening.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
DaveD
On Nov 8, 2020, at 11:06, Chuck Harris <cfharris@erols.com> wrote:
|
|
Chuck Harris
I don't think so. Dennis's emails are stuck in the infinite
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
retry loop, which seems to mean that Colin's ISP is set to drop on the floor all emails that it doesn't want to receive. It considers them spam, and as such, unworthy of acknowledgement. The sender's ISP retries... and retries... and retries.... This is a common technique, as it wastes the spam sender's resources and time, and costs Colin's ISP little or nothing. -Chuck Harris Dave Daniel wrote:
If that were the case, Dennis’ emails would bounce, which is not happening.
|
|
Dave Daniel
Ok. It’s fine that you don’t think so.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
DavdD
On Nov 8, 2020, at 12:57, Chuck Harris <cfharris@erols.com> wrote:
|
|
Dave Voorhis
On 8 Nov 2020, at 12:05, Colin Herbert via groups.io <colingherbert=blueyonder.co.uk@groups.io> wrote:
I have belatedly thought of another route to examining this oddity. ApartYou can check domains at https://mxtoolbox.com/blacklists.aspx to see if they’re blacklisted by any of the various anti-spam services. I note that blueyonder.co.uk <http://blueyonder.co.uk/> is not listed on any blacklists. However, ridesoft.com <http://ridesoft.com/> is on no less than eight blacklists. That guarantees that some email sent to ridesoft.com <http://ridesoft.com/> addresses won’t get through, because some will be blocked by the sender’s outbound mail service — usually their ISP — and some will probably be blocked as incoming email by blueyonder.co.uk <http://blueyonder.co.uk/>, assuming ridesoft.com <http://ridesoft.com/> email is redirected to one or more addresses at blueyonder.co.uk <http://blueyonder.co.uk/>. I’ve never seen a domain on eight blacklists. One or two isn’t unusual, particularly if a domain runs a variety of public email-based services like email-based forums or Web forums with email-based registration confirmations, but eight…?! Either ridesoft.com <http://ridesoft.com/> is being explicitly reported for sending spam (which doesn’t necessarily mean it is sending spam), or it is inadvertently sending spam due to running misconfigured or legacy services that can be exploited. For example, some old email mailing list software can be hijacked into sending spam, as can various “auto-responders” originally intended to send out automated announcements, as can misconfigured email servers.
|
|
Chuck Harris
And, there we have it.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Dennis owns Ridesoft.com As I said in an earlier posting, he is a lightning rod for any of a wide number of prickly members that disapprove of his moderation rulings. It was done to me, and it looks like it was done to Dennis. All anyone has to do is send his email to spamhaus as being associated with spamming, and he will be blacklisted by any number of different ISP's... With no good methods of recourse. Sure, you can fill out their form with all manner of your private and personal information, and if they so deem you worthy, they will remove you from the list... But why would you send private stuff like that to a group that behaves the way that they do? -Chuck Harris Dave Voorhis wrote:
On 8 Nov 2020, at 12:05, Colin Herbert via groups.io <colingherbert=blueyonder.co.uk@groups.io> wrote:I have belatedly thought of another route to examining this oddity. ApartYou can check domains at https://mxtoolbox.com/blacklists.aspx to see if they’re blacklisted by any of the various anti-spam services.
|
|
Dave Voorhis
On 8 Nov 2020, at 23:23, Chuck Harris <cfharris@erols.com> wrote:
And, there we have it.To my knowledge, Spamhaus runs just two of the usual 94 blacklists, and indeed a sometimes controversial one. Being on one can be a bit annoying for a while, but usually doesn’t last or cause significant disruption. (Though I appreciate that the, say, one sender who can’t reach you might be _very_ important.) But getting on eight blacklists — of which the Spamhaus DBL is just one — suggests broader malicious reporting than just Spamhaus, and perhaps more than just malicious reporting. Getting on a blacklist usually requires machine-verifiable evidence of “spamming” (I use the term loosely, because some blacklists employ a broad and perhaps controversial definition) because bogus reports are common. Getting on a blacklist usually happens because you have an inadvertently open mail relay (rare, but happens) or a flawed email autoresponder (not uncommon) or running an email mailing list with a “help” responder (some are almost guaranteed to get you blacklisted now and then) or sending bulk emails that you don’t think are spam (and maybe aren’t) but the blacklist organisation does.
|
|
Chuck Harris
Hi Dave,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I understand that. I pick on Spamhaus, because I had to deal with them when I was DOX'd by a member of this tekscopes. My point is the various blacklists work with the philosophy of shoot them all, and let god sort them out later. There was a time when there were several popular plugin apps along the lines of SpamAssasin, which would on the user's press of a button, send a victim's email address and ISP address to dozens of different blacklists as a spammer. And, the blacklists would gleefully add that victim to their kill list. I know that I was blocked that way by a member of this group, and it seems very likely to me that Dennis was as well. A person would be wise not to use an important email address on this group. -Chuck Harris Dave Voorhis wrote:
On 8 Nov 2020, at 23:23, Chuck Harris <cfharris@erols.com> wrote:And, there we have it.To my knowledge, Spamhaus runs just two of the usual 94 blacklists, and indeed a sometimes controversial one. Being on one can be a bit annoying for a while, but usually doesn’t last or cause significant disruption. (Though I appreciate that the, say, one sender who can’t reach you might be _very_ important.)
|
|
Roy Thistle
On Sun, Nov 8, 2020 at 03:23 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
Spamhaus doesn't accept spam reports, from individuals.
|
|
Roy Thistle
On Sun, Nov 8, 2020 at 01:36 PM, Dave Voorhis wrote:
Yes I see that...however Spamhaus claims it's not on any of their lists... however, the mxtoolbox "blacklist tool" does list it as being on Spamhaus DBL The same goes for "Spam Eating Monkey" and "Spam Open Relay Blocking System"... Ridesoft.com... they claim... is not on their lists. From what I can tell, Ridesoft.com is not currently being blocked.
|
|
Stephen Hanselman
I would agree, Spamhaus is a bit of a pain BUT they were also very easy to work with. One of my systems was compromised, and had put over 200,000 emails in my outbound queue. It was very creative to fix. An email to Spamhaus with the explanation and after a week or so the system was removed from their list.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On the other hand folks like Baracuda and Trend Micro make decisions based on, amount other things, what your reverse dns looks like or if the e-mail came from a dynamic IP. In our case AT&T switched some dynamic addresses to static when they switched from ADSL to Fiber. No amount of trying has gotten even a sign of a response from either of them. Regards, Stephen Hanselman Datagate Systems, LLC
On Nov 9, 2020, at 07:23, Roy Thistle <roy.thistle@mail.utoronto.ca> wrote:
|
|
Dave Voorhis
From the sounds of past problems, ridesoft.com _was_ blacklisted, but perhaps enough information appeared here for Dennis to progress getting ridesoft.com unblocked. There may be caching involved, such that 3rd party mxtoolbox.com still sees ridesoft.com as blacklisted whereas going directly to the blacklisters doesn't. That would make sense if ridesoft.com was quite recently unblocked (for an unspecified value of "quite recently," of course.)
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message-----
From: TekScopes@groups.io <TekScopes@groups.io> On Behalf Of Roy Thistle Sent: 09 November 2020 15:46 To: TekScopes@groups.io Subject: Re: [TekScopes] Email contact oddity - Spam Blacklisted? On Sun, Nov 8, 2020 at 01:36 PM, Dave Voorhis wrote: Yes I see that...however Spamhaus claims it's not on any of their lists... however, the mxtoolbox "blacklist tool" does list it as being on Spamhaus DBL The same goes for "Spam Eating Monkey" and "Spam Open Relay Blocking System"... Ridesoft.com... they claim... is not on their lists. From what I can tell, Ridesoft.com is not currently being blocked.
|
|
Vince Vielhaber
They don't NOW. They used to and had multiple lawsuits filed against them.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Vince.
On 11/09/2020 10:23 AM, Roy Thistle wrote:
On Sun, Nov 8, 2020 at 03:23 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:Spamhaus doesn't accept spam reports, from individuals.
|
|
Chuck Harris
Good! They should have been sued out of existence for that behavior.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-Chuck Harris Vince Vielhaber wrote:
They don't NOW. They used to and had multiple lawsuits filed against them.
|
|
n4buq
AFAIK, Craigslist used to (and, may still) do that sort of thing. If someone flagged your reply to an ad as spam, you could no longer get a reply through the system to anyone's posting email address and, to my knowledge, there was not recourse to undo that. I had to start using a different email address for C/L replies as no one was seeing my responses.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Thanks, Barry - N4BUQ
----- Original Message -----
From: "Chuck Harris" <cfharris@erols.com>
|
|
Jim Strohm
Also, if your ISP has open relays or is itself a spamhaus, you're likely to
get caught up in a wide net. My ISP the first time I ran for US Congress (2006) got flagged as a spamhaus, and hence my primary email got blacklisted. Because of the quaint storage systems on the internet, like the Internet Wayback Machine and others, I kept getting various flags until I left public politics in 2014, even after I took my campaign website down. I'll be paying for those domains until the day I die. If I didn't, they'd be snarfed up by porn sites and aliased. Yay for the internet. Hey, go to the Internet Wayback Machine and try February 2000 "Bish the Cat" "texas.net" and see what you find. I think it's cool that some of my stuff is still around when it's old enough to buy booze. Your stuff is still out there too. 73 Jim N6OTQ
|
|
Dave Voorhis
Being known to a anti-spam list is different from being blacklisted. Most healthy domains will be recognized by roughly 80 - 100 spamlists on mxtoolbox but won't be blacklisted by any of them. It's not clear whether that means the spamlist actually maintains a record of the domain or simply approves it vs ignoring it (perhaps for not being resolved by DNS within some timeout period.)
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I just tested a spammer domain picked at random from my inbox and it was resolved/listed on only 8 spamlists but was clearly blacklisted by one of them. I note that ridesoft.com also is resolved/listed on only 8 spamlists but now doesn't show as blacklisted by any of them. Why it only resolves on 8 whilst other domains are resolved by many is not clear, but I note that mxtoolbox tools show some other email/SMTP problems with ridesoft.com, including slow connections and lack of a reverse DNS record, which may cause email delivery issues apart from any past/current blacklisting.
-----Original Message-----
From: TekScopes@groups.io <TekScopes@groups.io> On Behalf Of Roy Thistle Sent: 10 November 2020 03:45 To: TekScopes@groups.io Subject: Re: [TekScopes] Email contact oddity - Spam Blacklisted? On Mon, Nov 9, 2020 at 08:12 AM, Dave Voorhis wrote: I checked with mxtoolbox domains I know are not on Spamhaus, and never were... or haven't been for a very long time. mxtoolbox reported some of them were on almost 100 blacklists... which is ridiculous.
|
|
Colin Herbert
I have been keeping quiet on this topic which I opened for fear of irritating more friends on here. I have contact with Dennis now on a different email address; it is my old employer's email server at Imperial College, London and is taking Dennis' emails with no problems.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I have had about 16 members who have contacted me directly at my personal email address and I have responded to those that I received. If anyone wants to contact me and is having problems like Dennis has described, I also now have a gmail address which is: colin.g.herbert@gmail.com Thanks to all for their patience and help, I hope this can all be settled soon. Colin.
-----Original Message-----
From: TekScopes@groups.io [mailto:TekScopes@groups.io] On Behalf Of Dave Voorhis Sent: 10 November 2020 09:07 To: TekScopes@groups.io Subject: Re: [TekScopes] Email contact oddity - Spam Blacklisted? Being known to a anti-spam list is different from being blacklisted. Most healthy domains will be recognized by roughly 80 - 100 spamlists on mxtoolbox but won't be blacklisted by any of them. It's not clear whether that means the spamlist actually maintains a record of the domain or simply approves it vs ignoring it (perhaps for not being resolved by DNS within some timeout period.) I just tested a spammer domain picked at random from my inbox and it was resolved/listed on only 8 spamlists but was clearly blacklisted by one of them. I note that ridesoft.com also is resolved/listed on only 8 spamlists but now doesn't show as blacklisted by any of them. Why it only resolves on 8 whilst other domains are resolved by many is not clear, but I note that mxtoolbox tools show some other email/SMTP problems with ridesoft.com, including slow connections and lack of a reverse DNS record, which may cause email delivery issues apart from any past/current blacklisting. -----Original Message----- From: TekScopes@groups.io <TekScopes@groups.io> On Behalf Of Roy Thistle Sent: 10 November 2020 03:45 To: TekScopes@groups.io Subject: Re: [TekScopes] Email contact oddity - Spam Blacklisted? On Mon, Nov 9, 2020 at 08:12 AM, Dave Voorhis wrote: I checked with mxtoolbox domains I know are not on Spamhaus, and never were... or haven't been for a very long time. mxtoolbox reported some of them were on almost 100 blacklists... which is ridiculous.
|
|