Date
1 - 20 of 72
Scope grounding and generators
Robert Simpson
Is there a safe way to use my 465M to look at my generator output? The generator I recently acquired will have its own ground separate from my house. In use that won't be a problem as I will only be hooking appliances to the generator with extension cords separate from house power . However, since I don't want to initially power the scope from the generator until I check the generator output, I am worried about working with two different ground connections.
Bob
|
|
Chuck Harris
Probably the safest way would be to use a filament transformer. It will
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
affect the fidelity of the signal somewhat, but is way better than you might think. -Chuck Harris Robert Simpson via groups.io wrote:
Is there a safe way to use my 465M to look at my generator output? The generator I recently acquired will have its own ground separate from my house. In use that won't be a problem as I will only be hooking appliances to the generator with extension cords separate from house power . However, since I don't want to initially power the scope from the generator until I check the generator output, I am worried about working with two different ground connections.
|
|
Robert:
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I don't see any reason why you can't check the generator output by connecting it to a scope (to monitor the waveform and/or voltage), subject to the following (in the US, at least). I assume that your generator is producing single phase power, either 120 VAC single phase or 120/240 VAC single phase: 1. To begin with, there's no reason why you can't connect the generator's ground to your house ground. But do not make any other connections from generator wiring to house wiring. The ground (the National Electrical Code "grounding conductor") will generally be identified as a bare, or green insulated, or green with yellow stripe insulated, conductor. Generator (and house) current carrying conductors will be either neutral conductors (National Electrical Code "grounded conductor"), which are generally colored white or grey, or phase conductors (colored differently from the assigned colors for grounded and grounding conductors.) 2. Power up the scope from "house" power, using a probe with a sufficient voltage rating (many 10x probes are rated to 600 V). You will need to make a grounding connection from the scope ground (scope chassis) to the generator ground; this can be either an individual "stand alone" conductor, or the shield/braid of the scope probe. I recommend a separate conductor rather than the scope probe shield; an alligator clip jumper cable should be sufficient. (Note: beware of cheap alligator clip jumper cables with crimped connections at the alligator clips; the connections should be soldered.) The US standard NEMA 5-15R (15 amp) and 5-20R (20 amp) 3-terminal outlets have the grounding terminal sized to accept a 3/16" diameter metal rod; I've successfully used pieces of round copper or brass rod to provide a good grounding stud, and then used alligator clip leads to extend the ground connection. 3. Provided that you've got the ground jumper in place, you should be able to probe the generator's output connector individual pins with the scope probe's tip. And you won't need to connect the scope probe's grounding clip to the generator's frame (as this connection will be accomplished by the alligator clip jumper cable described above. If probing a 120 VAC outlet (3 terminal), you should wind up reading 0.0 volts when probing the ground pin, and 0.0 volts when probing the neutral pin, and ~170 VAC peak (340 volts peak-to-peak) when probing the "hot" terminal of the 120 VAC outlet. Of course, make sure that you've got the scope set up with a "less sensitive" vertical deflection; 5 V/div should be adequate if you are using a 10X probe. I know that there have been quite a few threads on TekScopes dealing with possible safety issues when using isolation transformers, or autotransformers (e.g. Variacs) that "carry thru" a ground connection when testing switch mode power supplies, but I don't see any of these issues applying for what you are describing. But I've been wrong before, so I hope others will correct me if I'm wrong on this issue. Mike Dinolfo N4MWP
On 10/24/20 3:59 PM, Robert Simpson via groups.io wrote:
Is there a safe way to use my 465M to look at my generator output? The generator I recently acquired will have its own ground separate from my house. In use that won't be a problem as I will only be hooking appliances to the generator with extension cords separate from house power . However, since I don't want to initially power the scope from the generator until I check the generator output, I am worried about working with two different ground connections.
|
|
stevenhorii
Would you check the outlet the scope is plugged into to be sure hot and
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
neutral have not been switched?
On Sat, Oct 24, 2020, 17:54 Mike Dinolfo <mdinolfo@erols.com> wrote:
Robert:
|
|
Yes, I would check the outlet to be certain that the neutral and "hot"
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
connections are not swapped. But I would probably do this with a commercial grade plug-in tester (available at most hardware stores; typically under 15 USD, I believe); such devices typically have three neon lamps; two of which are supposed to glow, and one of which is supposed to stay dark with a properly wired outlet. Although an oscilloscope could also be used for this; I just think the special-purpose tester unit is the way to go. Or a multimeter can be used for the same purpose by measuring the voltage from the "hot" outlet terminal to ground, and from the outlet "neutral" terminal to ground. This applies to both the house wiring and the generator wiring. In the several decades during which I've been a homeowner, every one of the several homes that I've owned has had at least one outlet that was miswired when I bought it. So it's a worthwhile thing to check. I've never owned a generator; I suspect that the manufacturers generally know what they are doing, but it's a simple thing to check. Mike Dinolfo N4MWP
On 10/24/20 6:37 PM, stevenhorii wrote:
Would you check the outlet the scope is plugged into to be sure hot and
|
|
Robert Simpson
Since I will not be connecting the generator to house power, I should be safe connecting house ground for my scope test. I want to see the shape of the power, the frequency and peak voltage. I think a scope will be my best tool for that. Besides, why have a scope if I don't use it whenever possible?
|
|
Robert Simpson
Also, I just checked the main breaker panel and the ground and neutral are on the same bus bar.
My extension cord for the scope will have a triple tap on the end. So I can use one of the ground hole sockets to connect to the generator frame lug for this test . That way the scope ground and generator ground will be connected electrically close. Bob
|
|
Bob, I am reproducing your email with a few response comments... and it
might also be helpful if you indicate what type of generator you have (KW rating, voltage/phases output, etc). Also, whether you plan to monitor the generator's output with the scope receiving AC power from the house, or the generator itself: On 10/24/20 9:59 PM, Robert Simpson via groups.io wrote: Also, I just checked the main breaker panel and the ground and neutral are on the same bus bar.US National Electrical Code requirements call for the neutral (grounded conductor) to be bonded to the ground (grounding conductor) at the "service entrance" of any building service (but nowhere else); this is in accordance with "code". My extension cord for the scope will have a triple tap on the end. So I can use one of the ground hole sockets to connect to the generator frame lug for this test . That way the scope ground and generator ground will be connected electrically close.Yes, this will serve as an interconnection between the house ground system and any other loads (such as a scope plugged into the extension cord), or the generator's ground system. However: make sure that the wiring from the house to the scope (or generator) has not been compromised (insofar as maintaining the correct continuity of identification/wiring of neutral, ground, and "hot" wire) all the way from the service entrance, through intermediate outlets and the extension cord, to destination load(s) or generator. And you probably already know this, but I'll state it anyway- don't under any circumstances interconnect the neutral and/or "hot" wires between the house and the generator. Mike D. N4MWP Bob
|
|
Mac Perkins
Even if you have a dedicated ground rod for your generator, please bond (connect) that ground and your house ground (generally a bare wire coming from the ground rod to the electrical panel). Since a (three wire) extension cord from the generator to an appliance (eg refrigerator) will connect the generator's ground potential to the appliance, any difference between generator ground and house ground will present a shock hazard.
In general, all earth ground rods should be bonded together. Using a small filament transformer or repurposed wall wart (older iron core transformer type with AC output) is an excellent idea for safely observing the power line. As noted, the distortion is minimal and having no direct ohmic connection to the power line gives protection against unpleasant surprises in the case of the wiring not being as it should be.
|
|
Chuck Harris
At issue is how the generator is internally connected, and
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
the possibilities of accidents.... and on whether or not you are willing to bet your life that the generator is connected the way you think it should be, and that it hasn't any faults. For instance, you scope's ground wire is connected to earth ground through the power cord. Your generator should also be grounded, but if it isn't, an accidental connection between the generator's hot lead and the scope's ground, could cause the generator to be elevated 120V, or more, above the scope's front panel. As I stated earlier, I use a filament transformer for such measurements. Its fidelity is very good, and most are isolated for several hundred volts... actually many of the older filament transformers are good for 3000V. -Chuck Harris Robert Simpson via groups.io wrote:
Since I will not be connecting the generator to house power, I should be safe connecting house ground for my scope test. I want to see the shape of the power, the frequency and peak voltage. I think a scope will be my best tool for that. Besides, why have a scope if I don't use it whenever possible?
|
|
Simon
Be careful connecting appliances with a standby mode to a generator. On a couple of power cuts I connected my coffee maker to the generator and both times fried the standby circuit.
Simon
|
|
Jean-Paul
Robert: Most generators have a distorted sine output, depends on rating, and design.
Some have quite high THD. Other have terrible transients and EMI. Normally the mfg will have complete specs. Rule of thumb: Larger size and high cost - (10..50 kVA) are closer to sinewave, low THD and transients Cheaper consumer generators eg from Costco, under a few KVA, worse in every respect! What is your intended use, and what power levels, make and model of generator? I have used battery operated portables like TEK 212, rather than line powered scopes like 465M. But you can float the 465 with an isolation trsf. Good luck, Jon
|
|
Glenn Little
For safety, the generator should be grounded to the single point utility ground for the building it will be providing power to.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
The NEC probably requires this, I do not currently have access to a copy. MIL-HDBK-419 (available on the web) addresses grounding. Safety first. Ensure all grounds are bonded together. Glenn
On 10/24/2020 11:49 PM, Chuck Harris wrote:
At issue is how the generator is internally connected, and --
----------------------------------------------------------------------- Glenn Little ARRL Technical Specialist QCWA LM 28417 Amateur Callsign: WB4UIV wb4uiv@arrl.net AMSAT LM 2178 QTH: Goose Creek, SC USA (EM92xx) USSVI LM NRA LM SBE ARRL TAPR "It is not the class of license that the Amateur holds but the class of the Amateur that holds the license"
|
|
Chuck Harris
Isolating the scope may protect the scope from catastrophic
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
currents, but it does nothing to protect the scope's operator. The front panel on most lab grade scopes is grounded to the same ground as the BNC's, and as such the scope probes. If you connect the scope probe's ground to a voltage that is other than earth ground, the scope's front panel and chassis will be elevated to the same voltage as the scope's probe's ground clip lead. Don't do it! If your intention is to connect anything to *ANY* pin on a running generator, the generator must have its grounding point connected to a good earth ground. If you do not ground the generator any single point fault in the generator or load that shorts the hot lead to earth ground will elevate the generator's case 120 or 240V above ground. If your intention is to use a 465M, it too must have its chassis grounding point connected to a good earth ground. The only valid exceptions involve a whole lot of thinking, and isolating of the operator, scope, and generator from dangerous contact. Isolating grounds on test equipment and generators is a very dangerous "rookie" mistake. Read the "OPERATORS SAFETY SUMMARY" that is in some form in every Tektronix scope's manual since Tektronix stopped being rookies themselves. Why do I harp on such stuff? Because I made that rookie mistake when I was a teenager working alone. I was tuning up a transmitter, and for stability, I had the hand holding the diddle stick on the chassis of the transmitter, when I smelled smoke. Wanting to avert a catastrophe, I quickly reached over with my other hand and flipped the metal bat handled power switch on my intentionally ungrounded (for "safety" reasons) power supply. I woke up in a very battered state crumpled on the floor, up against a cement block wall. You don't have to repeat this experiment. It has already been done too many times. -Chuck Harris Jean-Paul wrote:
Robert: Most generators have a distorted sine output, depends on rating, and design.
|
|
-
I fried my refrigerator and the digital display board in my freezer when
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I connected them to a generator during a hurricane. They worked for a while but soon developed problems. Since then I've picked up a largish 440 or 220 to 220 or 110 volt transformer with dual primaries and dual secondaries that I can strap for the necessary voltage and I will connect my devices to the generator through it. Hopefully it will filter out some of the voltage spikes and higher frequencies (> 60Hz). Large transformers like this are frequently found in large commercial machinery and there's little demand for used ones so they aren't hard to find. The one that I have weighs about 40 pounds and is rated at 10kW IIRC so it should be able to handle my 5kW generator. A constant voltage transformer should work even better and they show up on places like E-bay frequently and usually sell for next to nothing because of their size and weight and the difficulty and cost of shipping them. I have several 300 W sized ones and they're slightly larger than a shoebox and weigh probably 20 pounds. I've been using them on my TV and some other equipment and none of it has ever been damaged despite nearby lightning strikes that took out a lot of unprotected equipment. The trick to buying things like this is to watch E-bay and look for ones within driving distance and to pick them up in person instead of shipping. Because of the shipping costs, these items get few bids and typically sell for the opening bid price. Also look for a dealer in surplus industrial and/or electronics equipment in your area.
On Sun, Oct 25, 2020 at 12:39 AM <tenareze32@gmail.com> wrote:
Be careful connecting appliances with a standby mode to a generator. On a
|
|
Tony Fleming
Are the new digital scopes also grounded to the earth ground? Only when
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
plugged into 120V and not using the battery that is inside to usually power my digital scopes. I like this diagram: https://images.search.yahoo.com/yhs/search;_ylt=AwrCmmD9e5VfhFgAbywPxQt.;_ylu=Y29sbwNiZjEEcG9zAzEEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Nj?p=connect+isolation+transformer+AND+oscilloscope&fr=yhs-iba-syn&hspart=iba&hsimp=yhs-syn#id=9&iurl=https%3A%2F%2Fi.stack.imgur.com%2F3bwTC.png&action=click I have a couple isolated transformers that I use when working on old stuff like Radios and TV's.... *My understanding is that as long the path can't find the earth ground in any combination, I should be safe.* Excluding my Tektronix 2465 DMS that is grounded to earth ground and in case I need to isolate my "path" I have isolation transformers for that. Many experienced people make mistakes even today, despite knowing this little problem that can cost $$$ or hurt you beyond repair. Am I wrong or is there a "path" that can "bite me anyway" ? Thanks.
On Sat, Oct 24, 2020 at 10:50 PM Chuck Harris <cfharris@erols.com> wrote:
At issue is how the generator is internally connected, and
|
|
Sean Turner
Chuck Harris makes a great point...don't repeat mistakes that have already been made. In his case, it might have cut his life short. It has cut short the lives of very experience engineers. If you're going to be making measurements on high energy sources, regular old lab scopes really aren't the thing. Get yourself a Fluke Scopemeter. These are designed to safely make floating measurements, and they have all the same protections that you get in a normal high quality multimeter (especially, nothing that might be live for you to accidentally touch).
Don't play Russian Roulette with your life. Sean
|
|
Dave Voorhis
On 25 Oct 2020, at 17:31, sdturne@q.com wrote:
Chuck Harris makes a great point...don't repeat mistakes that have already been made. In his case, it might have cut his life short. It has cut short the lives of very experience engineers. If you're going to be making measurements on high energy sources, regular old lab scopes really aren't the thing. Get yourself a Fluke Scopemeter. These are designed to safely make floating measurements, and they have all the same protections that you get in a normal high quality multimeter (especially, nothing that might be live for you to accidentally touch).Aren’t the venerable Tek 222, 222PS, and 224 also intended for that kind of use, up to about 400 or so volts on the probes?
|
|
Sean Turner
Sure, if you have one of those it is probably suitable as long as it's in good condition.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
The point I was making was that the OP really should get the right tool, be it a scopemeter, a 222/222PS, etc. A laboratory oscilloscope is not the right tool for scoping high energy circuits. Just because you can doesn't mean you should! Sean
On Sun, Oct 25, 2020 at 10:46 AM, Dave Voorhis wrote:
|
|
Robert Simpson
First , thanks everyone for the feedback. I do want to be safe.
So, I haven't, don't and won't be floating the scope. Never have and don't see why I would. In the house if I need that type of measurement, I would use my 7A22. For my generator test, the scope will be plugged in normally which means the scope frame will be at earth ground. By only temporarily connecting the generator frame to house earth ground, I don't see danger. Again, my only use of the generator will be with extension cords. No plans on connecting the generator to house power. The generator is a Briggs & Stratton Powermate 5000. Which is 5000 watts max continuous and 6250 surge. My use is planned at less than 4000 watts. (small freezer, refrigerator, one light and two small muffin fans in my heating wood stove.) as a side note for my motivation, you may have seen news articles about power shutdowns in California. Bob
|
|