Date   

Servo controller 1 vs 2 #question

Czar <czar551@...>
 

Hello everyone,
i was wondering if i could have benefits from the second version of servo controller against the first version. I’d really appreciate it if you help me decide it.
 Clear Skies 


Re: Superstitious

paul K
 

Thanks Martin and Yann-Eric, Yes something is 'loose' somewhere causing the 'bag of nails noise'. There's no clutches on this one and when I rotate the dec axis it feels and sounds different in different places. Lucas Mesu has aksed to look by webcam.

Being an I.T. type of person, you might imagine I have several dozen backups of the Sitech config and Servo Config. (well, I might have :) )

Fingers crossed, I'll post back

Paul


Re: Quite A Learning Curve

paul K
 

I would concur with others on this, one dual core 2GHz laptop with 4G RAM and WIn 7 will be absolutely fine. I ran all my systems from a Toshiba laptop with that spec up until three years ago. The only reason I changed was because the laptop was returned to its owner! I ran Sitech, Sequence Genarator Pro, PHD2, my SBIG Camera and guider, Pyxis rotator and Cartes Du Ciel simultaneously. Worked a treat.

best wishes
Paul


Re: Quite A Learning Curve

Don W
 

Hi Rusty,
That thinking doesn't apply now to ASCOM  guiding using PulseGuide, which SiTech uses.  Pulseguide measures the error and sends a required correction in terms of arc-sec to the controller (inside the PC), then SiTech controller moves the mount (quickly) to correct the error.  Guiding responses are now quicker than ever before.

Your old way required a timing correction pulse via the comm port to make the correction, and that was easily interfered with by other comm activity.  All that is ten year old technology that isn't a problem anymore.
Don W


Re: Quite A Learning Curve

Rusty Fletcher
 

Thank you for your help Don! The only reason for using two laptops is that when I used Mel Bartels software the tracking was always better (resulting in better images) when I used two laptops. The guide scope software was able to update the guiding corrections faster (because it was running on a dedicated laptop) and nothing interrupted the download of my primary imaging camera because that was also happening on a dedicated laptop. In practice everything seemed to just work better and faster when I set up two laptops. Also I am using two older laptops, both of them are: Core 2 Duo Processors @ 2.2 GHz and 4GB RAM running Windows 7.


Re: Quite A Learning Curve

Joshua Hufford
 

Hi Rusty, I'm thinking the same thing as Don. Why would you want to use two PCs for this? No reason you can't do it from one and make things much simpler. 

Josh

On Thu, Apr 22, 2021 at 9:21 PM Don W <westergren@...> wrote:
Hi Rusty,
Welcome to the SiTech world.  It is so easy to do all that from a single PC or laptpop.  I really doubt you can connect to two PC's with a comm splitter, but you are welcome to try.
Don W


Re: Quite A Learning Curve

Don W
 

Hi Rusty,
Welcome to the SiTech world.  It is so easy to do all that from a single PC or laptpop.  I really doubt you can connect to two PC's with a comm splitter, but you are welcome to try.
Don W


Quite A Learning Curve

Rusty Fletcher
 
Edited

I have used Mel Bartels stepper motor telescope control system for more than 20 years. I recently decided to upgrade to the SiTech servo motor system. I purchased the motors and electronics about a week ago and have not yet done the physical upgrade to my scope. I am studying the manuals, help files, and currently trying to familiarize myself with the software and everything I need to know to control my telescope with this new system. Do I understand correctly that I can connect two laptops to the same serial port, at the same time, on the SiTech Servo 1 controller using a straight through DB-9 Serial "Y" splitter? The reason I am asking is I would like to run SiTechExe connected to the Servo 1 controller, and control my primary imaging camera with my first laptop, while running my guide scope software (PHD) and sending ASCOM guide commands directly to the Servo 1 Controller from a second computer. Can this be done simultaneously? Thank you for any advice!

Rusty F.


Re: Superstitious

Yann-Eric Boyeau
 

By the way,

 

For those who are interested in Mesu group : https://groups.io/g/Mesu-Mount

 

YE

 

De : Sitechservo@groups.io <Sitechservo@groups.io> De la part de Yann-Eric Boyeau
Envoyé : vendredi 23 avril 2021 09:19
À : Sitechservo@groups.io
Objet : Re: [Sitechservo] Superstitious

 

Hi Paul,

 

It might be the DEC axis encoder that was not tightened enough and got loose.

It is hidden in the counterweight bar housing under the DEC plate.

I already inspected these parts on my Mesu 200M mk1.

 

We might continue to discuss the issue on the Mesu group or send me a PM as this is not closely related to Sitech Controller.

If the Dec encoder is simply loosened, this is a small issue and easy fix.

Lucas can have a look with you by webcam.

 

YE

 

 

 

De : Sitechservo@groups.io <Sitechservo@groups.io> De la part de paul K
Envoyé : vendredi 23 avril 2021 05:44
À : Sitechservo@groups.io
Objet : [Sitechservo] Superstitious

 

I'm not a Superstitious person, but it did occur to me a few posts back when I mentioned about my MESU 200 that 'nothing had ever gone wrong with it, that it might just be tempting fate.

So today I was doing some daytime tests with the dreaded meridian limits to work out a good eastern limt for my situation, and when I parked the mount, the Dec axis started sounding like a shaken bag of nails. I got the Sitech error

encoder tracking error

And the mount stopped moving which I guess is good.

Anyone got any experience of how to take the beast apart to inspect? There's lots of hex head bolts.....There used to be a MESU 200 forum on Yahoo, I'll see if I can find that too.

thanks,

best wishes
Paul


Re: Superstitious

Yann-Eric Boyeau
 

Hi Paul,

 

It might be the DEC axis encoder that was not tightened enough and got loose.

It is hidden in the counterweight bar housing under the DEC plate.

I already inspected these parts on my Mesu 200M mk1.

 

We might continue to discuss the issue on the Mesu group or send me a PM as this is not closely related to Sitech Controller.

If the Dec encoder is simply loosened, this is a small issue and easy fix.

Lucas can have a look with you by webcam.

 

YE

 

 

 

De : Sitechservo@groups.io <Sitechservo@groups.io> De la part de paul K
Envoyé : vendredi 23 avril 2021 05:44
À : Sitechservo@groups.io
Objet : [Sitechservo] Superstitious

 

I'm not a Superstitious person, but it did occur to me a few posts back when I mentioned about my MESU 200 that 'nothing had ever gone wrong with it, that it might just be tempting fate.

So today I was doing some daytime tests with the dreaded meridian limits to work out a good eastern limt for my situation, and when I parked the mount, the Dec axis started sounding like a shaken bag of nails. I got the Sitech error

encoder tracking error

And the mount stopped moving which I guess is good.

Anyone got any experience of how to take the beast apart to inspect? There's lots of hex head bolts.....There used to be a MESU 200 forum on Yahoo, I'll see if I can find that too.

thanks,

best wishes
Paul


Re: Superstitious

MartinC
 

Hi Paul,

Forgive me but just from the outside looking in it sounds like too much of a coincidence that the mount should suddenly develop a problem whilst you were 'working' on it. Generally I don't believe in coincidence. Are you sure you've not accidentally changed a setting related to the motor or encoder? 

I guess you have your config files backed up? If so maybe reload them before looking for a mechanical or electrical problem.

Best wishes 
Martin



Sent from my Galaxy


Re: Superstitious

paul K
 

yes it's from 2015 Jaspal
best
Paul


On Thu, 22 Apr 2021 at 19:52, Jaspal Chadha via groups.io <jaspalchadha=icloud.com@groups.io> wrote:
Mark1 I assume Paul ? 

Kind Regards 

On 22 Apr 2021, at 19:44, paul K <paulskirk53@...> wrote:

I'm not a Superstitious person, but it did occur to me a few posts back when I mentioned about my MESU 200 that 'nothing had ever gone wrong with it, that it might just be tempting fate.

So today I was doing some daytime tests with the dreaded meridian limits to work out a good eastern limt for my situation, and when I parked the mount, the Dec axis started sounding like a shaken bag of nails. I got the Sitech error

encoder tracking error

And the mount stopped moving which I guess is good.

Anyone got any experience of how to take the beast apart to inspect? There's lots of hex head bolts.....There used to be a MESU 200 forum on Yahoo, I'll see if I can find that too.

thanks,

best wishes
Paul


Re: Superstitious

Jaspal Chadha
 

Mark1 I assume Paul ? 

Kind Regards 

On 22 Apr 2021, at 19:44, paul K <paulskirk53@...> wrote:

I'm not a Superstitious person, but it did occur to me a few posts back when I mentioned about my MESU 200 that 'nothing had ever gone wrong with it, that it might just be tempting fate.

So today I was doing some daytime tests with the dreaded meridian limits to work out a good eastern limt for my situation, and when I parked the mount, the Dec axis started sounding like a shaken bag of nails. I got the Sitech error

encoder tracking error

And the mount stopped moving which I guess is good.

Anyone got any experience of how to take the beast apart to inspect? There's lots of hex head bolts.....There used to be a MESU 200 forum on Yahoo, I'll see if I can find that too.

thanks,

best wishes
Paul


Superstitious

paul K
 

I'm not a Superstitious person, but it did occur to me a few posts back when I mentioned about my MESU 200 that 'nothing had ever gone wrong with it, that it might just be tempting fate.

So today I was doing some daytime tests with the dreaded meridian limits to work out a good eastern limt for my situation, and when I parked the mount, the Dec axis started sounding like a shaken bag of nails. I got the Sitech error

encoder tracking error

And the mount stopped moving which I guess is good.

Anyone got any experience of how to take the beast apart to inspect? There's lots of hex head bolts.....There used to be a MESU 200 forum on Yahoo, I'll see if I can find that too.

thanks,

best wishes
Paul


Re: message to all members regarding wiki idea

paul K
 

Just as an update on this, I have the MediaWiki software installed now. I will take a look over the next few days and see what I can find out. I found a basic / beginners tutroial on youtube.

If anyone knows a good mediawiki tutorial which covers creating the user group, setting permissions etc that would be helpful.

best wishes
Paul


Re: message to all members regarding wiki idea

lunaticoastro
 

Me too I like the idea!

Thanks Paul

Jaime


On Sat, Apr 17, 2021 at 2:20 PM MartinC via groups.io <mncrane=virginmedia.com@groups.io> wrote:
Hi Paul, 

I think that's a very interesting suggestion. We have something similar (different format) where I work for technical support issues. I reckon it would need to feature some form of configurable search facility but to answer your question I think your idea has merit.

Best regards
Martin



Sent from my Galaxy


Re: Meridian Flip Settings Explained

MartinC
 

Hi Don,

As promised I have converted the video to a different format. From the following link you should be able to play it using Windows media player or the Films & TV app in W10. VLC media player is a free app that will play just about any format & is available for MAC or PC.

https://1drv.ms/v/s!AneSiXQRo7prjBRzU_e0UVaJ8I3Z?e=ymEZsK

Alternatively if know which format you prefer I'll try my best to provide it for you.

Best regards
Martin


Re: Meridian Flip Settings Explained

MartinC
 

Hi Paul, 
Yes that's it exactly. My observatory is small compared the the scope size. The dew shield is always very close to the dome walls & the shutter threshold is quite high. The difference in dew shield height between starting imaging with weights up/down is approx 1.6m. So if I begin imaging weights up either in the east or the west my scope can't always 'see' over the shutter threshold. That's why I need it to flip on goto's so that I can begin imaging a new target weights down. I'm happy for it to track past the Meridian until I run out of useful sky.

So my criteria are:
I need it to flip on goto's 
I need it to track past both Meridian
I need it to operate with the Meridian in the correct place; not st a Meridian that's been artificially moved to a different place in the sky.

Best wishes 
Martin



Sent from my Galaxy


Re: Meridian Flip Settings Explained

paul K
 

Hi Martin, just to show my lack of understanding of this subject, if it's a flipless mount, why do you need it to flip on Goto? What would be the criteria for that? I thought the idea of flipless was you could point at an object rising on the eastern horizon (scope would be pointing east) and you'd just track that right through to the west? I guess your observatory building might be a constraint for that as counterweights go up as you track. I've obviously missed something.

best,
Paul


Re: Meridian Flip Settings Explained

MartinC
 

Hi paul, yes it's very useful. I used it a lot when I was writing my dome driver as you can test during the day as if it were imaging for real.

By the way I've checked my video & that check box is meant to be selected as I need my mount to flip on Goto's.

Best regards
Martin

621 - 640 of 33573