Re: 8Gb RPI4 info...

Dave Wade



Excuse the rant that follows….


The remark was merely to disarm the “well Linux is faster” brigade, who insist its mana from heaven, yet every time I try it and then attempt to install some (simple) software I fall down some hell hole of library clashes.

The latest battle was with “cmake” which is also supposed to be the “42” of makes, yet trying to get a recent version of it onto my lubuntu box makes the 12 labors of Hercules seem like a gentle Sunday stroll, and the conjugation of Spanish verbs straight forward.


I ended up manually copying the binaries into /usr/local/bin. Folks tell me this may make future updating “hard” but seeing as there are only 4 or 5 I am sure I can easily delete them later when I need to this and allowed me to install openwebrx and get my SDR going. Just to get closer to the topics, I was trying the lubuntu box (HP Miniserver) just to see how much interference my PI generates on 2mtrs. The answer seems to be “a lot” so next task is linear PSU for the PI…


As for “others” well not that’s current. RISC is hardware, not software. Solaris might work, but the Intel port is picky about hardware. NT4 or Windows/2000 would probably be OK but so long out of support not worth trying.

Really its just poor hardware. The Intel Atom CPU is optimized for low power consumption. The battery lasts for three or four hours. However whilst the designers fulfilled this part of the design, it seems, they forgot that to be useful it needs to execute more than one instruction a fortnight….


… as for operating systems getting in the way, well in normal times I demonstrate the replica Baby at the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester


… and having only seven instructions and 32 words of storage it makes event a PIC chip look like a Super Computer, never mind an Arduino




(and yes its me on the picture. Only because they wanted a lady as well and Christine was there….)




From: <> On Behalf Of Lawrence Macionski via
Sent: 09 June 2020 15:19
Subject: Re: [RaspberryPi-4-HamRadio] 8Gb RPI4 info...


your comment "it doesn’t matter which OS, Windows/XP, 7 or 10, or a host of light weight Linux systems. All are equally slow)" Is there better? some RISC or perhaps obscure "Solaris"?   Don't get me wrong, to me the O/S is like going to a restaurant. You get to choose, tables, dine in or carry out. eat on the patio, Punch the chef in the nose. To get to the meat and potatoes--- the program.. and the speed you get it. depends on if it's been compiled and how good that is, or natively written in machine code, and just how many people do that these days. Not I since the 6502 days...

So given any O/S once you select the program... it runs at some speed dependent on if it's using an interperator, or how good the complier is, or if someone actually wrote it in machine language. even then how many "calls" are being made to the O/S or drivers, and so on. Then on top of all of that, what overhead is going on.....An O/S does not necessarly determine speed of a "job" or the program. Speed is determined on many factors such as the number of processes running, cache, DMA's,  interrupts, swap space,  and who the programmer was and how he attacked and solved the programming task.

That's why the lowly ARDUINO works as well as it does, there is no O/S only machine language code running. Now it still can be tweaked by the quality of the compiler, and the programmers ability. to write the coding structure for efficient execution.

Back in the day of my 1st programming class at Henry Ford College maybe 1968, the instructor gave us a programming problem an engineering drawing of a block with various holes drilled in it. We were given a 2x4x4 piece of wood and loaded it into a NC drill press and ran our paper tape. You passed if you drilled the holes, right number in the right place, at the right depth...The instructor had a go-no go gauge that verified location and depth of holes. That was Pass-FAIL. Go-no GO. If Go,Your grade was determined by the instructor pinning the paper tape to the wall and who had the shortest paper the highest grade..  One gal had a paper tape twice as long as everyone else but by the GO-NO go  guage she passed. She had no idea as to how to be productive.  

So to me the O/s is an evil necessity in order to load, execute, move, copy, delete or save a program. Some early O/S's like CP/M and DOS batch, that's about all you could do.. old guys well know the program pip...

Join to automatically receive all group messages.