Re: [R1b-L513 Project] R1b-L513 Descendant Tree update
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Your Descendant Tree chart has Galbraith and McIntyre descending from Z17816, but they should descend from Z17813.
Do you know how these two men came to share/test the same SNP in BY34838? Very interesting. Is this an example of where Alex's chart has fallen behind? I suspected this McIntyre was different from the other L193 McIntyres, especially since he (347690) and another McIntyre (57594) share the 640=13 STR and the latter does not share the very slow moving 434=10 which the other group of McIntyres (BY2634 suspected) share.
The 434=10 STR has been seen in L193-only men who have tested positive for BY2634, including Wood, Mcintyre, Ferguson, and Wilson. It seems apparent that 434=10 is a predictor marker for BY2634 amongst L193 men.
Recommendation for McIntyres: Those with 434=10 should test for BY2634, and possibly for some of the 7 private SNPs held by #676804 McIntyre. Click on the surname on Alex's chart to access private SNPs http://www.ytree.net/Disp
#57594 Mcintyre should test for the BY34838 SNP held by #347690 Mcintyre.
For the 7 McIntyres I've bcc'd with this email, please feel free to contact me for any clarifications. I match you all at 67 STR markers, and you are all at least L193/S5982, as I am: Darrel, George, William, Fred, Scot, Albert, Ted. See our public L513 Haplogroup Project pages here https://www.familytreedna.com/groups/r-l513/about/background
There are two types of Y-DNA mutations: STRs, and SNPs. STRs are what are used on our personal Matches pages. SNPs, often referred to as Haplogroups, are the only mutations we can use to build our paternal trees. See the left side blue background of the Descendant Tree Chart on the above link to our Background page for men descending from L193 man. L193 man was likely born around 2900 years ago, but all L193 men share a common paternal ancestor born approximately around 200 AD (my personal calculation).
On Feb 6, 2018 9:29 PM, "mwwdna@... [R1b-L513-Project]" <R1b-L513-Project@...> wrote: