Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Rick McGaver
Where are these on Sale?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
On Nov 23, 2021, at 8:17 AM, JUSTIN R "RANDY" PADAWER - K7RAN via groups.io <padawer@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: QCX+ Reciever audio fades out to zero seconds after startup
Hi Steve,
Forgive me for making absolutely no assumptions - I mean no offense, I just want to know how to respond: Here are four fundamental questions that I would ask you and all people asking for help to answer on their first post. Answer to these questions are extremely helpful in defining the possible scope of our diagnostic efforts... 1. Is this a factory build or a kit build? 2. What test equipment do you have available to you ? Do you have a DVM? An oscilloscope? A dummy load? 3. Can you read electronic circuit diagrams and identify components? 4. Do you have sufficient technical skills to accurately diagnose and replace components on the unit with support form this group? This unit works on a single power supply, and the receiver is predominantly a DC-coupled chain of operational amplifiers. This means that a lot of information can be gained by simply measuring DC voltages along the signal path. If either of the output pins (pins 1 and 7) of any of the operational amplifiers (IC5 to IC10) are at zero volts or at or above half your supply voltage, then you have a clear indication of the proximity of the fault. My first guess for the problem would be a leaky capacitor along the audio chain, so the voltage measurements suggested above would get us a quick read on unit health. -- Julian, N4JO. |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
John Terry (W0JDT)
Hi chris Have same experience. Success build, 1 week of good contacts, then receive lost. Initially could not get usb contact, but restarts got cat back, but no qdx sound card. more restarts, the qdx sound card but low receive, only occasionally decoding. DId 1.07 firmware update but no help. Now have red zone, no signals. Everything on the cat, transmit side ok. Since initial functioning was fine, doubt a solder/component problem, but have a non-functional unit. Was hoping to take this on POTA, but not going to happen. Thinking about factory reset, but no info on windows terminal program. Thinking about building another QDX, but can't say what I could do differently to get more successful outcome. Frustrating. John N0jt |
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Zhenxing Han N6HAN
5 sold in the last 24 hours lol
|
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Randy K7RAN
Mike (WA4MP), thanks for posting the link to the QRPometer kits for sale! Just clicked through and bought mine. :)
|
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
I'll add my voice to this. I have built two QCX originals, and two minis. Both of my originals worked perfectly the first time. The first mini had an issue with a capacitor that I may have caused by misreading the instructions and it took me several weeks to sort out, but was a success with the help of this group. The second one was a damaged one sent to me from another ham to repair, and I repaired it with Hans' help. I've made contacts with all of them. I got my 1000 miles per watt award with the first one. These kits are relatively low component count kits, and Hans has provided good trouble shooting videos, so most issues can be solved quickly with due diligence, a good soldering iron, and a multimeter.
-- 73, Dan - W2DLC |
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Great question! I've wondered the same thing.
I've built 2 QCX Classics. Both worked right away. I've built 2 QCX Minis - Both worked right away. I've also had the same results from my multi-band Ultimate 3S. Hans is the new Mr. Heathkit to me even if he doesn't design projects with tubes and big power transformers. (SMILE) IMHO, his assembly instructions are second-to-none. I think most of us would agree that Hans has brought new joy to our hobby/passion with his products as we wait eagerly at the computer screen awaiting his next release. Thank you, Hans. |
|
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFAB2a31yrA&t=130s
This is the result of my QCX-Mini build for the 15 meter band (5W at 11V) using a wire dipole antenna, having 100% of SOTA confirmations done. https://www.sotadata.org.uk/en/log/activator/show/580000 73 de PY1ZB Roney |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
Chris
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Try going into WSJT setup and changing the playback source to another source then changing it back. That has worked for me and may provide a clue. On Tue, Nov 23, 2021 at 03:42 AM, Christoph Schwärzler wrote: All, |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
Christoph Schwärzler
I was "lucky" and captured two log files from subsequent sessions, one successful and the other not.
The attached file "Sucess" was first: Powered the QDX up, entered terminal (PUTTY), cleared log, set log to "ALL", exited terminal, started WSJT-X, closed WSJT-X, entered terminal Just two minutes later, I restarted the QDX by unplugging power and than followed the same procedure as above. This time the WSJT-X showed the failure. The respective log file is "No success". Note: Both sessions were done with "Kenwood TS-440S". Very first tests with "Kenwood TS-480" showed no difference, but will try more. All other setup details, see my earlier post in this thread. 73 Chris OE1CGS |
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
I must say that the QCX+ was a joy to build, and I managed to get 5W out of my 40M and it works great. I have built two QCXs (a 40M and a 20M) they both work but don't put out as much power. Which I suspect is more a function of the builder than the build.
I can say that my success rate is much better than other kits that I have built, or half-built as the case may be. I have a shelf of partially completed kits with issues
☹ that I need to get back to.
I agree that the directions are the BEST and if you follow them you're going to be successful.
Thanks, Hans!
Kent KC9LIF
From: QRPLabs@groups.io <QRPLabs@groups.io> on behalf of Evan Hand <elhandjr@...>
Sent: Tuesday, November 23, 2021 6:03 AM To: QRPLabs@groups.io <QRPLabs@groups.io> Subject: Re: [QRPLabs] What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios? On Tue, Nov 23, 2021, at 05:28 AM, Curt M. (WU3U) wrote:
The thing about Hans kits is that the success rate is solely based upon the skills of the builder. By the time the board itself hits the street there are at least no major errors on it. Yes there have been some component changes and minor mods from time to time but no bad circuit boards. As long as you take your time and do everything carefully (including checking the integrity of the components shipped with the kit) you will have a successful build.Curt, Just a minor correction. In the first release of the QCX-Mini, there were reports of damaged surface mount components from the original SMD board supplier to Hans. This was one of the first kits that had a significant amount of surface-mounted devices (SMD), at least as far as I know. Hans took care of it right away and now does a 100% inspection of all boards coming in with a test jig that he designed and built. I would like to add that the QRP-Labs instructions are by far the best that I have seen. This greatly improves the success rate for builders. For our club of builders, I do not know of a kit that we have not been able to make work. The success of first power on I do not know other than personal experience and that is 100%. My current issues with the last kit I built (a QDX) are related to a new device and Hans is working on the root causes. Still, it worked out of the box it was later failures that brought out the issues. 73 Evan AC9TU |
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Evan Hand
On Tue, Nov 23, 2021, at 05:28 AM, Curt M. (WU3U) wrote:
The thing about Hans kits is that the success rate is solely based upon the skills of the builder. By the time the board itself hits the street there are at least no major errors on it. Yes there have been some component changes and minor mods from time to time but no bad circuit boards. As long as you take your time and do everything carefully (including checking the integrity of the components shipped with the kit) you will have a successful build.Curt, Just a minor correction. In the first release of the QCX-Mini, there were reports of damaged surface mount components from the original SMD board supplier to Hans. This was one of the first kits that had a significant amount of surface-mounted devices (SMD), at least as far as I know. Hans took care of it right away and now does a 100% inspection of all boards coming in with a test jig that he designed and built. I would like to add that the QRP-Labs instructions are by far the best that I have seen. This greatly improves the success rate for builders. For our club of builders, I do not know of a kit that we have not been able to make work. The success of first power on I do not know other than personal experience and that is 100%. My current issues with the last kit I built (a QDX) are related to a new device and Hans is working on the root causes. Still, it worked out of the box it was later failures that brought out the issues. 73 Evan AC9TU |
|
Re: QDX - RX and TX stopped working on 80 meters only
Hi Evan, thanks for your comments.
I wrote my message a few days ago and I suppose it took time to get approved because it was my first post. Since then I have tried every combination on startup of antenna on or off, the way the power is connected and battery versus power supply. The only thing that seems to work with my QDX is to rapidly cycle the power using the switch on the power supply and even that doesn't work all the time. For the startup frequency I have done the factory reset quite a few times which always results in a startup frequency of 0.707405 as I mentioned. I did figure out how to edit the startup frequency in the configuration - only PuTTY works properly, minicom and screen don't. I think it is probably the way that the backspace character is handled by the QDX that is the issue but I haven't explored it further. In any case when I use PuTTY and edit the frequency it still is wrong on startup. In answer to your question about which radio, I am using the TS440S setting and CAT seems to work perfectly. For now I have put the QDX aside without torturing it anymore as I'm thinking there will be a firmware change coming soon :-) Rick |
|
Re: What is the actual "success rate" for home built QCX+ radios?
Curt M.
The thing about Hans kits is that the success rate is solely based upon the skills of the builder. By the time the board itself hits the street there are at least no major errors on it. Yes there have been some component changes and minor mods from time to time but no bad circuit boards. As long as you take your time and do everything carefully (including checking the integrity of the components shipped with the kit) you will have a successful build. Curt |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
William Smith
It may not be related, but since I grounded my case I have not had any unexplained 'suddenly stops working' issues.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
73, Willie N1JBJ
|
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
Christoph Schwärzler
Hi,
Evan, in WSJT-X v2.4.0 there is no "Kenwood TS-440" available, I am using "Kenwood TS-440S". I will check into the "Kenwood TS-480" as suggested by you. Alan, the period covered by the log is several days and a couple of sessions. No wonder, some errors are shown on several occasions. I cleared the log this morning and will set to "ALL" for the next session(s). 73 Chris OE1CGS |
|
Re: QDX - RX and TX stopped working on 80 meters only
Evan Hand
Rick,
One other question I forgot to ask was which radio do you have selected in the WSJT-X settings? Evan |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
Evan Hand
Hi Chris,
In addition to Alan's suggestion and question, I would add the radio that you have selected in the WSJT-X settings file. I noted that the QDX reports a Kenwood TS-480 but the manual says to use the 440 first. Have you tried the alternate radio? 73 Evan AC9TU |
|
Re: QDX - RX and TX stopped working on 80 meters only
Evan Hand
On Tue, Nov 23, 2021, at 01:29 AM, Rick MacDonald / VA1UAV wrote:
Everything is working fine with mine except I have the same startup noise issue that Evan and Gregg have described. In my case turning the power off and then back on quickly seems to consistently fix the problem.Hi Rick, For the startup audio issue have you tried starting with the antenna disconnected from the QDX? That seems to help me at times. For boot-up frequency, did you try doing a reset to factory defaults? The other thing that I noticed is pressing the left or right arrow keys while the cursor is on the startup frequency then pressing the backspace key deletes the frequency. For my setup, I run a Raspberry Pi 4 or a Windows10 laptop. Both on WSJT-X 2.5.2 Most of the time My QDX Info:
Evan AC9TU |
|
Re: QDX just stopped receiving
Alan G4ZFQ
There are two indications that something is wrong and they *always* come together: A *red signal strenght* indicator (79 dB) and an indicated *frequency of 0,707405*. For what it is worth I attach my log file. It was aquired with the "Errors only" setting.Chris, Hans is looking into this problem, hopefully he will come up with an answer. I do not know if the log will help but I suggest you log ALL for a short period until a fault occurs. Then save it. Clear for the next check. Your log shows a lot of errors but what period does it cover? From where did the unknown commands come? One fault or many faults? 73 Alan G4ZFQ |
|