Re: Info on UK steam kits
Jim King <jking@...>
Thanks for the help. I will contact him about making a frame, drivers and
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
valve gear. I can handle the rest of the engine and tender. If I can get him excited about this project, we will finally have HOn3 and On3 ten wheelers at a price far below that of quoted brass. Regards, Jim King SMMW Tuhr Barnes wrote:
From: Tuhr Barnes <TuhrBarnes@worldnet.att.net>
|
|
Re: Info on UK steam kits
Tuhr Barnes <TuhrBarnes@...>
I would suggest you talk with John Agnew of Railmaster Imports. He
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
produces in Sn3 and has quite a few kits under his belt. I model the ET&WNC in Sn3 and have a couple of his 2-8-0 kits. (Any other Sn3's for ET&WNC?) He produces excellent kits that go together very, very well. So far he has produced C-16's, C-17's, C-18's T-12's and SP narrow gauge ten wheelers along with Pacific Coast/Uintah 2-8-0's and White Pass Diesels. The frame and drivers come pre-mounted to ensure smooth operation. He also uses a NWSL gearbox and Sagami can motors. John's kits run just shy of $500.00 U.S. He also sells RTR versions for under $900.00. I don't know if he is at all interested in HOn3 or On3 but he is a very helpful individual. Now if you can get him to do it in Sn3, I would be mightly grateful! John's E-mail is: John@railmaster.co.nz He also has a web site at: www.railmodel.org.nz/Sn3/ Last weekend he was in Pasadena for the Sn3 Symposium, I don't know when he is headed back home. Tuhr Barnes Bob Webber wrote:
|
|
Re: Info on UK steam kits
Bob Webber <rswebber@...>
I would try Backwoods Minitures - address in the Gaz - he didn't have a a
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
e-mail address last time. He's made some climaxes in Sn3, Garrats, etc.from 9mm on up. Great looking stuff. Bob
At 08:40 PM 2/16/99 -0500, you wrote:
From: Jim King <jking@ioa.com>
|
|
Response to Rick Steele's comments
Jim King <jking@...>
Rick,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I'm relatively new to this list, but the pro and con discussions about new steam models is very old and continues to go 'round and 'round with no resolution in sight. Your comments are what's primarily being addressed here, but the overall mood of my comments pertains to the whole issue of "what new kit do we ask for". While most of the comments are accurate, relative to marketability, subject matter, cost, etc., there are a couple points I take issue with. Being a model manufacturer myself, I have a different perspective on the subject of "what the modeler wants". First off, I have nothing against Colorado narrow gauge. The fact that many lines were built at all tests most engineering principles to the max! Other than the Doe River Gorge on the ET&WNC, there are few examples of typical Colorado terrain in the east. But I don't live in the West and have no interest in modeling western roads. I live in North Carolina ... and I do take offense to the "Puking Buzzard" comment you made. This state is home to the "ET", Lawndale and many other ng lines that now only exist in text or memory. Despite the comments made by several subscribers to this list, there IS a good market for eastern subjects not related just to EBT. Ed Cass' book on the OR&W has helped bring that well-known road to light. Soon, the Mann's Creek book will be out. My point is, don't think narrow gaugers exist only in Colorado just because that's where 3' trains still run. Second, I take issue with the subject matter of what should/shouldn't be imported. If a manufacturer is tooling up for a die cast boiler, frame, cylinders, et al, then yes, he should appeal to the widest market to get a return on investment because a single-cavity die-cast mold can easily run $60,000-80,000! And you'd better plan on running a minimum of 15,000-20,000 shots from it to get a payback. Kits made from etched brass, urethane and white metal DO NOT require such tooling investment, just time to make patterns and rubber molds or artwork for the brass. Sure there is a lot of time invested, but more time than tooling dollars, so the subject matter can be economically produced without a second mortgage on the house. These processes are aimed at short run, limited production subjects. Get your kit(s) when they are first available, 'cause they won't be around forever. Same principle as brass imports ... once they're in the states, you'd better have yours reserved or it's likely to be gone when 'you get around to it'. Just because the "mass concensus" says to produce yet another Colorado prototype, that's no reason to blindly ignore the eastern modelers. As a small manufacturer who does not make a living by making kits, I can be very selective on the next kit's prototype. That's why I've joined groups like the ET&WNC HS and have answered their requests for HOn3 rolling stock by producing, short-run urethane kits of the hopper and a flat, so far. Although my personal interests are now in On3, I plan to continue the HOn3 product line because this group has supported my efforts as they said they would. You mention imported brass prices being so high. Yup, they are now in the collector's realm ... almost exclusively. Too bad .. there are a lot of nice models to be had, but most of us would need to win a lottery to afford just one anymore. With the hopes of an eastern prototype being imported in HOn3, the ET&WNC Historical Society is currently taking reservations for a set of the 4-6-0s that made the prototype famous. They are now working with their third importer and the jury's still out on the outcome. In the meantime, there is no accurate ng power available, but 2-8-0s can be cobbled up to "get close". And, I've seen the estimated retail price of the ten wheelers approaching $1000. Too pricy for me. So the option of a brass/white metal/urethane mixed kit are again looking promising. In conclusion, don't get blindsided by all the Colorado-hype. With today's varied manufacturing techniques, there is no reason why we all can't get closer, if not nearly exact, to the desired model and not just "settle for close enough". Once the frame and running gear have been established, the superstructure and tender are relatively simple. Use your imagination, collect data and present it in a logical format to a prospective manufacturer. You might be surprised to see "your" model be produced in a year or two. Jim King Smoky Mountain Model Works Asheville, NC Rick Steele wrote:
CHoefer533@aol.com wrote:The various K-series locos appear like a rash in the Brass Caboose catalog!You say "like a rash" and then say "NO OFFENSE". Young bucko, I AM offended. I
|
|
Info on UK steam kits
Jim King <jking@...>
Hi all,
I've read with great interest the various comments about a UK source for a US-based prototype. Can someone pass on to me the name and email address to the recommended source(s)? I'm interested in producing an HOn3 and On3 ET&WNC ten-wheeler in a combination of brass, white metal and urethane. The mechanism has always been the stumbling block, particularly drivers, so if we can resolve this issue plus frame and can-motored drive, I can handle the rest. Thanks to anyone who responds. Jim King Smoky Mountain Model Works
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
Curtis Brookshire <curtis.brookshire@...>
I do have the letter. It listed the levels of recognition by amount of
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
donation. It made no references to making payments toward a goal, which is what prompted my question in the first place. I leave it up to the Society's officers to decide what to do on accounting. In the meantime, I'm sending in donations by the month. If I don't get recognition, so be it. The goal is to get Combine 15 restored, not to receive a certificate. Curtis
-----Original Message-----
From: John Waite <jwaite@dragon.desoto.k12.mo.us> To: Tweetsie@onelist.com <Tweetsie@onelist.com> Date: Thursday, February 11, 1999 9:18 AM Subject: [Tweetsie] Re: Combine 15 Donations From: John Waite <jwaite@dragon.desoto.k12.mo.us>
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
John Waite <jwaite@...
Send the money. We'll keep up with payments. I'll just keep adding to the
amount in the data base. SHOW ME THE MONEY! John Waite Technology Coordinator De Soto Public Schools Email: jwaite@dragon.desoto.k12.mo.us 221 S. 3rd Voice: 1-314-586-1005 FAX: 1-314-586-1009 De Soto, Missouri *Aut inveniam viam aut faciam* *I shall either find a way or make one!*
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
John Waite <jwaite@...
Curtis,
It was my intent that you would be able to make payments and that they would accumulate toward a particular level. I don't have the letter here with me right now so I don't remember whether I put it in the letter. Sorry if I didn't make it clear. John Waite Technology Coordinator De Soto Public Schools Email: jwaite@dragon.desoto.k12.mo.us 221 S. 3rd Voice: 1-314-586-1005 FAX: 1-314-586-1009 De Soto, Missouri *Aut inveniam viam aut faciam* *I shall either find a way or make one!*
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
johnny graybeal
My first knee jerk reaction would be to make a pledge, with a date that it
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
will be sent, and then wait until that date to send it. Keeping up with it any other way would be a nightmare. On the other hand, John Waite is in charge of the fund raising, so what ever he thinks. This project may stretch out for years. We can always take more money from you later if you want to give more. Tax deductions work every year.
-----Original Message-----
From: Curtis Brookshire <curtis.brookshire@gte.net> To: Tweetsie Group <Tweetsie@onelist.com> Date: Wednesday, February 10, 1999 2:55 PM Subject: [Tweetsie] Combine 15 Donations From: "Curtis Brookshire" <curtis.brookshire@gte.net>the restoration of Combine 15. The sheet also listed different categories ofgoal. What's the window for these donations? I would like to see us be able to
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
fwest@...
Gary Scoggin's idea of a pledge seems workable. Churches do that, for
instance, so they can estimate a budget.mw
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
Ken Riddle <ken290@...>
Great idea Curtis!
Ken ---------- From: Curtis Brookshire <curtis.brookshire@gte.net>the restoration of Combine 15. The sheet also listed different categories ofgoal. What's the window for these donations? I would like to see us be able to
|
|
Re: Combine 15 Donations
Gary B Scoggins <Gary.B.Scoggins@...>
Just send a pledge and when you've accumulated the total send it in. Bits and
pieces I'd think will make accounting a nightmare. My opinion for what it's worth.
|
|
Combine 15 Donations
Curtis Brookshire <curtis.brookshire@...>
Members of the ET&WNC Historical Society received a request to donate to the
restoration of Combine 15. The sheet also listed different categories of recognition based on the amount of donation. I have a question to ask the Society officers and our group in general: Could members make payments to a goal? I may want to give, let's say for example five hundred dollars, but can't do it right now. Let's say I can send fifty to seventy five dollars for several months until I reach my goal. What's the window for these donations? I would like to see us be able to make payments and think this will result in a higher overall donation. What do you think? Curtis
|
|
Trip to ET RWY
fwest@...
Over this past weekend, a friend and I traveled to Johnson City in
beautiful weather and saw the Nr 214 diesel recently pruchased by the ET. It is gorgeous!! Southern green and white with gold letters and, from what I could see was beautifully restored. I believe it to be an SW 1200, but perhaps Jim Six could ID that better. One of the older black and orange diesels was still in the enginehouse, so has not yet been moved to its new owner. After photographing the engine, we went to look for ETWNC roadbed. The owner of the ROW just east of tunnel Nr one was very nice and let us drive part of the way and walk the rest to the tunnel and the site of the covered deck bridge. I was aware that that tunnel had been gouged out of solid rock when the ETWNC was anticipated to be a five foot gauge RR in the early 1800's, but had no idea the tunnel would be so large. The other tunnels are not nearly so large, but this one was truly magnificent. It was clean, though there was evidence of a campfire, and safe, and at the end were the abutments to the covered deck bridge. After photographing the tunnel and bridge abutments, we went down hwy 321 and turned rt onto Stevens Road which took us to within a couple hundred yards of the other covered bridge abutments at Hampton. On exiting back onto 321, we crossed and went down to the Doe River Christian Camp. The people there were just as pleasant as could be (and even said nice things about the historical society in general and Johnny Graybeal in particular!!). They took us on a tour of their replica boxcars and ex-CSX work cars, showed us a couple of motorcars, and let us have free reign to walk the roadbed, which we did. It took abt an hour to walk through tunnels two and three, gaze at the beauty of the Doe River Gorge and arrive at Pardee Point. There is NO litter, the roadbed is in remarkably good condition, and the place is safe, beautiful, and interesting. We cleared some rocks which had fallen and some tree limbs off the roadbed at a few places, but it got to be a much bigger job after Pardee Point leading to the bridge, and it was getting late, so we returned. The folks that operate the camp said the society members were always welcomed to visit if we would just check in with them and they asked that we not visit from June 1st to Mid-August because of camping activities by 8 to 18 year old camp kids. We saw a few needs for switch targets and we have a few extras, so we will return later this spring and mount the targets for the camp people and will do it in the name of the ETWNC Hist Society unless someone objects. The new diesel, a tour of the roadbed and the tunnels, all in beautiful weather with nice people. It dont get better than that!!mw
|
|
Re: The six pilot coupler
fwest@...
Ill take a shot at an answer. Perhaps Johnny Graybeal can correct me.
Perhaps during the timeframe you mentioned, the 2-8-0 engines no longer were being used in the Johnson City yard or in any other connection with the standard gauge operations, so the three-way coupler was removed and placed on one of the 4-6-0's which interconnected with both standard and narrow gauge cars. That doesnt answer the resulting drop in coupler height, but could answer the changing of the coupler.mw
|
|
The six pilot coupler
Sergent, Frank <Frank_Sergent@...>
Tweetsie Experts:
Does anybody have an idea why the number six's front coupler was changed and moved down between 1909 and 1925? This is opposite of the general idea that ET&WNC engines got higher 3-way couplers over time. The photo on page 5 of the Jan-Feb-Mar 98 Stemwinder shows #6 with what appears to be a high mounted 3-way coupler in 1909. The photo on the front cover of the shows the same engine in 1925 and the back cover shows it in 1929 with a much lower non 3-way coupler. Note the different cut bar configurations also. This would seem indicate that at least some rolling stock had low couplers (24"?) as late as 1929. Any ideas??? Thanks in advance, Frank Sergent
|
|
Re: Update on trucks
Curtis Brookshire <curtis.brookshire@...>
Sounds great! Continue marching forward.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Curtis
-----Original Message-----
From: Jim King <jking@ioa.com> To: On3 Group <on3@onelist.com>; ET&WNC HS Email List <Tweetsie@onelist.com> Date: Tuesday, February 02, 1999 10:45 AM Subject: [Tweetsie] Update on trucks From: Jim King <jking@ioa.com>
|
|
Update on trucks
Jim King <jking@...>
Hello all,
Last week, I spent a very enjoyable evening with Paul Redmond of On-Trak Models in eastern North Carolina. Among other things, one topic was making inexpensive, quality trucks for HOn3 and On3 (with 30" gauge options, too). Bottom line is that I can make the patterns of the various ET&WNC (my main interest) side frame styles for him to spin cast in a Zamac/pewter mixed metal. The bolsters will likely be urethane, similar to what Design Tech recently advertised in the Gazette. No screws will be needed for assembly ... just slide the side frame tab into the bolster slot and add a small styrene 'cap strip' over the slot to keep in place. Slight equilization should be maintained but is not critical to smooth operation on smooth track. We can get the sideframes in any style, including McCord and Simplex and in any gauge by using new urethane bolsters. Any photos or other info you folks can loan me toward this project would be most appreciated. If you have any info, let me know offline, please. Thanks, Jim King Smoky Mountain Model Works
|
|
Re: Printer Cartridge refills
RICKY WILCOX <rickywilcox@...>
---
Ricky Wilcox On Fri, 29 Jan 1999 22:26:31 Mike West wrote: From: fwest@Charleston.Net (Mike West)DO YOU OR ANY BODY HAVE ANY "USEFUL" INFORMATION ABOUT THE RAILROAD. WELL I HAVE TONS OF INFORMATION ABOUT THE ET&WNC OR TEETSIE. I'M A ET&WNC MEMBER. I LIVE CLOSE TO TWEETSIE IT A COUPLE OF MILES UP THE ROAD. WELL I GO TO GO RICKY WILCOX Get your FREE Email at http://mailcity.lycos.com Get your PERSONALIZED START PAGE at http://personal.lycos.com
|
|
Re: Printer Cartridge refills
fwest@...
The list is called "Tweetsie" because we are interested in the railroad;
not business development.mw
|
|